saeldur":2m17l6s9 said:
What's your advice or thoughts on water fasting? I did it last year for roughly 2 weeks, I ate once a day and the rest was pure, filtered water. In my experience it made my skin completely clear, not a single black head or spot in sight, got rid of my menstrual cramps that were really common for me and I lost about 3kg. Yes, it was difficult but IMHO it's worth it as long as you don't do it for too long and have one meal a day. If anyone has heard of Athene (WoW pro gamer) he was on a water fast for about 8 days recently for charity, he lost quite a lot of weight and said he felt really good after it.
DON'T DO IT
oh god oh god oh
all my old friends in california jump from one fad diet to the next. they just got off of their fascination with the juice fasting diet. i get so tired, talking myself until I'm blue in the face about how silly they are.
here's the thing: fad diets and fasting don't work.
if you want to lose weight, it is extremely important that you continue to intake the vitamins and nutrients you need, and keep your metabolic rate going. the latter of which can only be accomplished through eating.
when people fast (ever, on anything), they shock their bodies into saying "OH GOD IT'S THE DROUGHT OH GOD". Your metabolism drops so you burn less calories. Your body wants your fat SO GOD DAMN MUCH. It will do ANYTHING to hold onto it. Usually sudden drops in food intake = drops in brain activity and muscle breakdown/regeneration. which is probs the last thing you want while trying to work out and get fit.
anyone will lose weight significantly at the beginning of a fast, for the first 3-5 days. your metabolism hasn't slowed yet; it's still operating at the efficiency that you set through your normal caloric intake. but over time, you will notice significantly diminishing returns.
and, here's the kicker: when you stop fasting, your metabolism will be so lethargic and slow, any time you eat anything, your body will make it priority #1 to squirrel it away into fat.
so much for the pounds lost while fasting: you'll gain them back just as fast, unless you do an incredibly slow, incremented increase of intake over a period of time.
also: you noticed a change for the better in your skin because water is really good for your skin. most people don't drink enough water. on a water diet, you're probably going to be drinking a lot more water than you normally would.
and if you only eat one meal a day, you'd damn well better make it breakfast, so you can wake up your metabolism and try to burn it over the course of the day. but most fasters only eat after sunset. which is not a good idea for weight loss.
here's the bad part: you can't work out on a water diet. you're not getting enough electrolytes (carbs, sodium), nor enough protein, to replace muscle.
when you work out, your muscle tissue is broken down by lactic acid, so it can be rebuilt, more dense. for that rebuilding, you need nutrients.
another bad part: your digestive system is a very slow adapter. your stomach will continue to produce just as much acid as it is used to. fasts are often accompanied (usually, later) by erosion of the stomach lining, esophageal lining. acid reflux, ulcers. your colon and intestines may over-lubricate and you'll experience ... er, muddy waters.
your brain alone sucks up a huge amount of nutrients to function. how much exactly is very difficult to determine, but if you're ever not feeling like you're at your 'A'-game, chances are good that you're not providing it the energy it requires. snakes and lizards can go ridiculous amounts of time without eating. because, if they just sit still, their bodies on their own expend very little energy. but their brains are the size of split peas. human brains are weirdly large for our bodies, in comparison to pretty much any other creature on the planet. they are inefficient power-mongers, is why. and it's not about to shrink, so unless you want to feel dopey and fatigued 24/7, you should continue to feed it (especially carbs! brains love carbs).
losing weight can be as simple as cutting calories in increments of 500/day (don't drop below total 800-1000 cals/day, depending on how tall you are), and doing some exercise. if you're only in it to lose weight, it shouldn't matter what exercise you do (unless you're like sauk and you want to get really trim & muscley in certain areas, then the exercises matter a little more).