Shadow, I have a theme changer where people can change to whatever theme they want. I just have the default as a default right now though because we are crafting our own unique theme.
Despain, as I tried to explain, despite it's name, Tinyportal is no mere portal. It is a website construction environment for SMF. Let me try to clarify...
Create custom webpage based on own html and such...
1.) Takes a lot of time.
2.) You would have to utilize the SMF hooks if you want to loosely incorporate the forums into the website.
3.) You can't share membership databases (last I checked).
4.) However you do have the distinct satisfaction that it is all your own code
.
5.)Have to theme the site to match the forums.
Use a CMS (Joomla/XOOPS/Mambo)
1.)Just like creating a website, except you have pre-made tools and hooks.
2.) You have to use a clunky brindge for SMF that may or may not work (Joomla! doesn't have a bridge anymore for SMF).
3.) But it does save some time, and is your own work.. for the most part.
4.)Have to learn how to theme the CMS to match the forums.
A Portal Software (Typically MKPortal)'
1.)Is nothing more than a portal.
2.) MKPortal has a tendency to take over the forum.
3.)Is buggy.
4.)Still have to theme for both.
The Tiny Portal mod for SMF
1.)It already incorporates your forums (the portal feature).
2.) You can set it to whether or not you want the articles from the forums to display on the index page.
3.) As long as you make the theme compatible (add a simple header to incorporate tinyportal) you only need one theme, because they share the same theme.
4.) It incorporates all the mods of SMF (including FelBlog) With greater use and features.
5.)Despite it's name, it is not a portal software anymore. As my example should have shown, you create pages, and affect the website just as with any other CMS, but without the fall-backs of the CMS'es, and no need for bridging.
6.)Website administration is done within the SMF administration panel. Moderators and such can also be appointed over parts of the website.
I know what the first thought that comes to mind about the name Tiny Portal. You think it is nothing more than a simple portal that shows only what is on the forum. It is for that reason that I didn't use Tinyportal for such a long time, and tried hand coding and using CMS'es. However, after reading so much about it I finally tried it, and couldn't be happier. Tinyportal doesn't just put a portal for my forum, it builds an entire website around my member base.
In the end, it is up to you on what you want to do. However, I did think that I read one of the reasons for the switch to SMF was for better tools and easier use and such. This would definetly fall in line with that. I personally believe that much more could be accomplished, instead of fighting with a CMS that won't work, or hand-coding an entire website.
While I hope you will look more into it for the benefit of the community as a whole, I also do respect your authority to make what ever decision you decide to make. I just hope it is one you, and the community as a whole are happy with. It should always be remembered that a website community exists because of it's members, not it's administrators.