I'm going to write a semi-lengthy commentary...Not really a formal review.
I used to chill around the community, pretty unknown member, but I'll be honest, I only come here to see the progress on a couple of games, and MotW is #1. I cannot stress how much I enjoy your game. Flat out, if it were released on the SNES as is, it'd be the best game on the SNES. You guys balance playability, puzzles, fantastic dialog, and an epic plot perfectly. This is a production quality game.
Arc V was no exception. Fantastic Arc with crushing story telling.
Of course you always here positives and I feel like I should throw in my two cents on this Arc. Take em' as you will, just here are things I think you guys could improve.
Timeline:
Look I've been waiting for this Arc since February. No joke. You guys had a very solid 6 month cadence for Arcs being released, and this one took a year. I know you are busy. In fact its amazing you guys even get these things down while other projects die in the water. But at the same time, with the slip in Arc V's schedule, when will Arc VI be released? I think you guys should set a drop dead of August 09. But honestly I expect it to slip to January '10, but I can wait that long if its a huge awesome Arc.
My concern is that I can't go out and tell all my friends on the street to play MotW until its done. And I have at least a dozen friends who'd pick it up if I suggested it. Get it done
We are all relying on you
Arc 5 itself:
Many items I have issue with.
Stoic cutscenes:
Great, fantastic! I enjoyed them. And at the same time, since its been a year since Arc4... so the new information was having a hard time meshing with the old. The fate of General Mephisto (sorry I'm forgeting his name...) and other details would've been nice. Maybe you could post like, a volume or something that you can open up as an item...not for next arc, but in the final release of all arcs combined. It was just... sometimes we need a refresher or some more details.
Other than that, I cried, I enjoyed myself. I was rather surprised at Zeno's humble upbringing, he wasn't like a legend, he was just there with the legends... the entrance of Enkur was interesting, not needed though. Definitely liked the huge sprite though.
Sparrow Revelation:
I was surprised, to say the least. I thought it'd be Cade's brother or dad or something. But, nope Auburn. Definitely... Touching. I think the best part was the extra scenes at the end. That really drove the acceptance home. But i'll be honest. End of Arc IV had the best ending scene with Ariel. Holy balls that was awesome... Maybe more pazzaz next time
Battles:
Please add more enemies when you re-make it. Just crab things and Squids was... tiresome. And the squids are way too hard for that little experience.
Ariel:
After watching the end of Arc IV, I was excited to see Ariel. Sort of disappointing she didn't appear more.
Loose ends:
Honestly this didn't feel like the second to last Arc. The least you could've done was tie up a few of the loose ends...
Solik
Enkur
Rana
Beardedscholardudewhosenameiforgot (Cole Marin?)
Touten Corps
Hand
Ariel
Auburn (though I'm glad this one reaches into last arc)
etc
I guess I was just hoping someone important would die
Overall, fantastic Arc. I just have no idea how you'll wrap everything into a final arc and finish it up before 2010.
And of course, the polishing and bonuses you gotta add to old arcs when you do the final combined
Also sorry for the disjointed summary, I've been writing it for 2-3 minutes at a time since Sunday.