Well, I'm late to this party, but I gave the GEASS ending some time to sink in, and actually, I think at the end of the day it was pretty satisfying. Hell, good even. Though undoubtably somewhat like pretenting to be the second coming, with all the whole 'I'll shoulder the worlds hate and then get killed thing going on'.
And because I'm bored, I shall argue Ven's points. I agree that Geass is a comfort anime, though.
1.) it stars a high school kid who, for some stupid reason, has an adult mentality. this ties into #8
Mother shot dead and then getting exiled at like 12 won't do that to you, then?
2.) it takes place on earth but for some reason everyone has bright pink and purple hair and shit.
Thats just anime. The pallette excuse is usually: 'so you can differenciate the characters from one another'. Bullshit, probably.
3.) it has giant mechs the kids control with just like 2 switches/levers-- which ties into #8
Yeah, true, thats lazy. Then again, you only ~really~ need 4 levers (Accel, Brake, Clutch, Gearstick) and a wheel to control a car. All the lights and snazz are just fluff.
EDIT: Oh, I forgot, americans all drive automatics, don'tcha? So, actually, 2 levers and a wheel for you guys...not actually too far from that mecha...
And heck, flying a Jet Plane only involves so many buttons and levers because of the extreme conditions and speed of the transport involved. (Most of which is computerized these days in any case)
4.) most of the main character's main support team are also comprised of teens (there is a reason why armies don't allow you to enlist until you're 18 and that's because kids are fucking dumb!)
Huh? I can only really think of Kallen meeting that description. (and I guess Suzaku counts too) Rakshata, Toudou, Diethard, Ougi etc. are hardly teens. Also, don't they say a persons mental prowess actually peaks at 12 or something? Us oldies are only actually superior because of our experience and accumilated knowledge.
5.) the main character has a MAGICAL POWER FOR SOME FUCKING REASON (which ties into #8)
So? Again, its not real. Just because its set on alternate earth doesn't mean it has to follow the laws of physics too.
6.) all the typical anime archetypes are there! broody, serious boy. happy-go-lucky sweet girl. way-too-serious and "mysterious" chick. gung-ho empowered female. loyal patriot-type boy. Extremely effeminate antagonists. a couple of withdrawn nerds. the whole gang!
Yep, anime cliche at its finest. Again, whats the problem here?
7.) true to highschooler anime fashion, there is very bland, uninteresting romance that leads absolutely nowhere.
Probably because the fans would be in uproar more if he actually picked someone. I'll agree that is stupid, but thats the way it goes.
8.) it tries to be way too many things at once. a mech anime. a war anime. a highschool anime. a magic/arcane anime.
And actually doesn't do too bad, considering. True, there is a hideous amount of plotholes as a result.
9.) the main character in the dub is voiced by the fag who played Ichigo from Bleach
So watch the sub. Turn that fag off if you don't like him.
10.) it has the dumb emo shit going on with that half-assed "IM REALLY A PRINCE!!!!! LOL BUT IM SAD BECAUSE YOU KILLED DAD OR SOMETHING D: ALSO MY SISTER(?) IS BLIND OMG
Lelouches emo was surprisingly low, actually. Well, at least tolerable.
11.) the characters NEED TO EAT A CHEESEBURGER. why is everyone on the planet ANOREXIC???
CLAMP's art style is stupid tall. That is all.
12.) the main character is JAPANESE but his name is LELOUCH (hint: that's french and also japanese people can't pronounce L's)
As has already been pointed out, he's actually European. Britannian prince = not japanese.