Envision, Create, Share

Welcome to HBGames, a leading amateur game development forum and Discord server. All are welcome, and amongst our ranks you will find experts in their field from all aspects of video game design and development.

What are you favorite RPGs?

moog

Sponsor

my friend and i had this similar argument, his was a little dumber though. he said donkey kong country was an rpg because you role played as donkey kong LOL
 

Jason

Awesome Bro

So was Uncharteds story, doesn't make it an RPG, lol...

To be honest, I could NEVER get into the Megaman games, tried, multiple times, can't do it, they just seem like a bogstandard platformer, and don't interest me at all o.O
 

moog

Sponsor

Whoever reported above post, it wasnt a shitpost (mml games were made to be rpgs) so they are lumped into the action/rpg section
 
Megaman legends, hell yeah, I knew I forgot something. The first damn rpg(technically, again) that I played, loved the shit out of that game. 1st copy broke, and then I bought another. MML2 was also okay.

Megaman zero was a damn good series, though, so much better than the orginal or X(I've played mm8, mmx1, 2, 4, 5 and 6, so I know what I'm talking about). The gameplay and story actually meant something in MMZ.
 

candle

Sponsor

Super Mario Galaxy is not an RPG - it is action/platformer
Devil May Cry is not an RPG - it is action/ adventure
the Legend of Zelda is not an RPG - it is action/adventure
 
candle":znnkp5kp said:
Super Mario Galaxy is not an RPG - it is action/platformer
Devil May Cry is not an RPG - it is action/ adventure
the Legend of Zelda is not an RPG - it is action/adventure

EDIT: ok sorry, they're not RPGs but adventure games. O_o
 
There are lots of games with stories that are definitely not RPGs. Survival horror games such as Silent Hill or Fatal Frame have stories, but are not RPGs. Even first person shooters have stories. O.oa A story does not make a game an RPG instantly. RPGs do focus on stories more so than other genres/games, but that's it. ^_^ Candle is right on what he says. :3
 
"A role-playing game (RPG) is a broad family of games in which players assume the roles of characters, or take control of one or more avatars, in a fictional, or real, setting. Actions taken within the game succeed or fail according to a formal system of rules and guidelines. Role-playing games also include video games in which players control a character or team who undertake quests, and whose capabilities advance using statistical mechanics. Despite this variety of forms, some game forms that are related to role-playing games may not be included. Role-playing activity may sometimes be present in such games, but it is not the primary focus."
-Wiki

I know I used Wikipedia but it was reliable and correct enough to get the point across. Plus anyways, its ridiculous to try to define that Mario Galaxy really has a story. I have never heard of a P-RPG before either.

I personally like:

Pokemon, if you consider that an RPG
Paper Mario, again, some may consider this not to be one
Final Fantasy XII, I really loved all the extra stuff
Chrono trigger
FF Tactics

If there are more, Ill think of them later. o:
 

candle

Sponsor

9robin3":2fmttxuh said:
candle":2fmttxuh said:
Super Mario Galaxy is not an RPG - it is action/platformer
Devil May Cry is not an RPG - it is action/ adventure
the Legend of Zelda is not an RPG - it is action/adventure

Super Mario is a P-RPG BECAUSE it has a STORY!
DMC IS A partial RPG if you dont play Mission! It s cutscenes in it so yeah its an RPG
Zelda is Nintendos adventure games (wtf dont you see ADVENTURE games as RPGs?)

O_o

stop complaining. You dont define these as RPGs but I may do..

By your definition, almost any game can be considered an RPG. This is simply not true.
 
when did this topic become a definitional debate on what is a rpg?

I like legend of dragoon and think its actually only been mentioned once here. The dialog translations were crap in english, but the battle system was very traditional with that combo system that made it so much more than attack, attack, repeat. That and their defend command actually had a use.
 
I loved Chrono Trigger. It is something worth experiencing.
It is fast-paced and it did not have lengthy cutscenes. However, the fast pace did not detract from the depth behind the story.
I would call it one of the RPG masterpieces, but then again, that's my opinion.

Square should invest more into the series since the recent port sold one-million (according to VGChartz). That's pretty good considering the game was ported twice since the original.
 
candle":l7la60hd said:
9robin3":l7la60hd said:
candle":l7la60hd said:
Super Mario Galaxy is not an RPG - it is action/platformer
Devil May Cry is not an RPG - it is action/ adventure
the Legend of Zelda is not an RPG - it is action/adventure

Super Mario is a P-RPG BECAUSE it has a STORY!
DMC IS A partial RPG if you dont play Mission! It s cutscenes in it so yeah its an RPG
Zelda is Nintendos adventure games (wtf dont you see ADVENTURE games as RPGs?)

O_o

stop complaining. You dont define these as RPGs but I may do..

By your definition, almost any game can be considered an RPG. This is simply not true.

Ok sorry, you misunderstood me, these games I wrote is ADVENTURE games, I see that now, adventure & RPG is not the same thing. My apologies O_o
 
EDIT (after the hacker changed this): I still think Valkyrie Profile is very good, to bad I haven't played the 1st VP :P
 

Thank you for viewing

HBGames is a leading amateur video game development forum and Discord server open to all ability levels. Feel free to have a nosey around!

Discord

Join our growing and active Discord server to discuss all aspects of game making in a relaxed environment. Join Us

Content

  • Our Games
  • Games in Development
  • Emoji by Twemoji.
    Top