which is better?

[sweet_thing2090]

i know this sounds silly but i just want an opinion on character personalities. heres one character(bottom left):

i was originally gonna make her a selphie/riku (final fantasy) type character but then i thought of a maybe putting a ditzy kind of dumb character, silly, but different isnt it. or perhaps this could be for the male but i think opposite would be better but I want some views and opinions from you guys out ther. thanks

 

[NIGHTMARERPG]

i think they are too cartoony. maybe try a little more realism? unless thats what you want. if it is, nice job. this is good as it is.

 

[lunarea]

i think they are too cartoony. maybe try a little more realism? unless thats what you want. if it is, nice job. this is good as it is.

*confused* What does being "cartoony" or more realism have to do with the question?

@sweet_thing2090:
I'd probably go with something different. The character looks kinda sweet/ditzy, so it might be fun to make her personality the complete opposite. Like maybe she can be very smart or even a little mean. It would send an interesting message

 

[Tim.]

I'll agree with Lunarea... The last things RPG's need are more ditzes..

 

[Despain v.1]

Didn't you already make this topic.

 

[Wings]

No Des, this is the same topic but a moderator or admin moved this thread from RMXP Discussion to the Resource Analysis forum and removed the redirect I believe (which is that > Moved : xxxx text you see so often). :$

 

[Despain v.1]

No Des, this is the same topic but a moderator or admin moved this thread from RMXP Discussion to the Resource Analysis forum and removed the redirect I believe (which is that > Moved : xxxx text you see so often). :$

I wasn't talking about that. I was talking about the topic that the person made before which was an exact duplicate of this except with a black face too.

 

[Balore]

I think the second one looks best.

 

[lunarea]

I wasn't talking about that. I was talking about the topic that the person made before which was an exact duplicate of this except with a black face too.

Actually, I think the other topic was to choose a character look whereas this one is to choose a personality.

 

[sweet_thing2090]

Didn't you already make this topic. I wasn't talking about that. I was talking about the topic that the person made before which was an exact duplicate of this except with a black face too.

yeh i used the same pic but i was asking just the characters look-wise, im asking the personality now, just something that came up in my head

I'd probably go with something different. The character looks kinda sweet/ditzy, so it might be fun to make her personality the complete opposite. Like maybe she can be very smart or even a little mean. It would send an interesting message

like ff8 quistis , yeh i could go with that, hard to make some character different, squaresoft has done most of them.., i woz kinda going for that look to go with the personality, thats why i designed her like that