Envision, Create, Share

Welcome to HBGames, a leading amateur game development forum and Discord server. All are welcome, and amongst our ranks you will find experts in their field from all aspects of video game design and development.

The Test

So, this one's a bit tough to explain. I have a very particular muse who only shows up once every couple of years, and who likes to give me a particular brand of story. I don't really think I did this one justice, but I'm posting it here because I know I'll get some honest C&C, even though I'm pretty sure you guys will tear it to shreds in the process. Anyway, here you go.


The Test

Ann's alarm went off, and she opened her eyes. She looked out her window, where the sun was just peeking above the houses across the street. The sky was filled with the wispy puffs of cumulus clouds, which floated high above the town. There was a light breeze, and the thermometer in her window read 70° Fahrenheit, the best temperature she'd seen in ages. She looked around her room, at the books in her bookshelf, aligned perfectly and arranged alphabetically by author then title. She looked at the calendar next to her door, the days marked clearly and concisely, with "Test Results!" in bold lettering on today's date. "Oh, I get to see how I did on the test today!" She thought. "Mom and dad will be so proud of me!"

Ann got up out of her bed, quickly making it and smoothing the covers. She got dressed, making certain that everything she had placed the night before was still in perfect condition before putting it on. She headed down the stairs, and cooked herself some eggs and toast. She made certain that the eggs were the perfect consistency before she ate them. Her mother and father had already left for their jobs, so she left on her own. She locked the door behind her, and double-checked to make sure the lock didn't stick again.

Ann quickly made her way to her school, which was only a few blocks away. She was the first one to class, as always. Today, everyone seemed to be in a good mood, and her classes went without a hitch. Her friends were talkative, her lessons were easy, and even the bullies ignored her. Finally, it was her last class, the class where she would see the results of that all-important test. The test that would make her parents so proud of her. The test that would make all the work she had put into this finally, finally pay off.

The teacher began just like everyone said he always did. He praised the high marks everyone made, and told them how proud they had made their school. He glossed over the few tests that had apparently not been up to par, and added that overall, the class had been stellar. Then, he walked around the room, and handed everyone their marks. He told them not to open the envelopes until he had handed all of them out. Ann got hers, and could barely restrain herself. Finally, all of them had been handed to their owners, and Ann was allowed to open hers. She slowly peeled off the seal, careful not to mar the perfect cover to the document. Then, she looked inside.

She had failed. Not only had she failed, but she had the worst marks she had ever heard of anyone getting. They were abysmal, falling just short of having purposely tried to answer every question wrong. How could this be possible?! She had studied for weeks, months to prepare for this test. She had known everything she was supposed to know. The test had gone by so easily! How could this be possible?!

Slowly, she put the document away, and looked out the window. Clouds had rolled in, and it looked like a light rain was just starting to fall. She hadn't brought a jacket, since rain wasn't in the forecast for the day. She sat there, wondering what she could tell her parents. This was the test. This was the one they all led up to. She couldn't just tell them she had failed. She looked at the clock, wishing the class would end so she could go home. The seconds became minutes, the minutes became hours. The ticking of the clock became a dull thud, thud, thud, marking the time far too slowly to be possible. Finally, after what seemed to be eons, the class was over. She could leave the prison the class had become. Now, nobody seemed as friendly, and the bullies took notice of her on the way out of the building.

Slowly, ever so slowly, she trudged home. The rain soaked into her hair, causing it to muss and flatten to her head. When she got home, she opened the door and slipped inside. She locked the door, then made her way up to her room. She sat down at her desk and stared out the window for a while. She watched the storm get worse, and saw the sky darken and the thunder and lightning start. Eventually, she placed her head down on the desk, and just sat there, awaiting the inevitable.

There. The door opened. Her parents must be home. What would she tell them? How could she explain what had happened? How could she ever face them, knowing that she had let them down like that? She got up, and made her way down to where they would be. When she looked up, her face went white. These weren't her parents. They looked old and rotten. They looked like they had died and were simply moving about their routines on ghastly, undead clockwork.

She backed away as quietly as she could, and made her way to the kitchen. Her cell phone was dead, and they were next to the only land line. She couldn't call for help, then. She grabbed a knife from the shelf, and made her way back to where these things were. One of them looked up, and made some kind of noise at her. She lunged and stabbed it. She kept stabbing until it stopped moving. Her hands were covered in the rotten filth it exuded. Suddenly, she heard a ghastly wail. She turned to see the other one, looking at her from across the room.

She covered the ground between it and her quickly, and stabbed that one as well. She kept stabbing it until it was as motionless as the first one. She stepped back, then looked at her hands and the knife. They were covered in filth from these monsters. She sat down. Her mom and dad should be back soon, they would know what to do with these things. They would help her clean it up, and everything would be better. It would be like it was supposed to be.

Suddenly, she heard the doorbell. "Mom and dad must be back!" she thought. But then, she stopped. Why would they need to ring the doorbell? They had keys, they could let themselves in. She looked to the door, and edged back, realizing that more of these things must be on the other side. Suddenly, the door broke in, and several of the monsters shuffled in. They saw her and came to a halt. She took advantage of the pause, and hardened her grip on the knife. She lunged at them. Then, all of a sudden, she was on her side. She could see the window from here. She could see the bright sunny day, with the high cumulus clouds throughout.

All of a sudden, the acrid smell of the filth on her hands and knife changed, becoming the sharp tang of copper. She looked at them, and was shocked to see they were no longer covered in putrid filth. Instead, they were saturated with fresh, scarlet blood. Her eyes widened, and she looked to the side, in the direction of those monsters she had first slain. There, she saw her parents, lying on the floor. They were covered in the marks of her own blade. "Mom! Dad!" she thought. "No! This isn't right! They'll still save me! Then everything will be back to how it should be!" Slowly, everything faded to black.

"I'm dead." She thought. "I killed Mom and Dad, and now I'm dead." She paused, regarding the blackness around her. "This is...familiar." She had been here before. Slowly, ever so slowly, it was coming back to her. "I've been here before?" She thought. "I have, but how?" Then, it hit her. "No!" She screamed. "Don't send me back! Don't make me do it again! Mom! Dad! Save me! Help me! This isn't how it should have been..." Then, she was silent.

Ann's alarm went off, and she opened her eyes. She looked out her window, where the sun was just peeking above the houses across the street. The sky was filled with the wispy puffs of cumulus clouds, which floated high above the town...
 

candle

Sponsor

to be honest, i almost did as well. try saying those sentances alloud. See how bad they sound? no one would ever talk like that except for small children and the mentally handicapped. Im sure you can do much better. Think about what you would say on a day like that? Personally, I might go with, "Yes! The results come out today," and leave it at that.
 

moog

Sponsor

candle youre the man, you took the words right out of my mouth

sorry glitch but anyone with a brain and some sort of general literary sense knows that the flow of that vernacular is terrible. the dialog is really lame and stale; the overall plot is pretty insipid too. and if the response to this is "it gets better", save it. short stories are supposed to draw you in as a pre-requisite. not my cup of tea
 
Y'all some negatives here, me however, i quite liked it, it might be insipid to some and the dialogue is stale but i liked it.
 
I understand the dialogue isn't exactly normal, but there's a reason for that. Specifically, in this piece, details matter. Why would she be using dialogue like that? Because she has some problems, which you would have seen if you read through the piece a bit further than you did. That being said, I do agree. The dialogue is not what a normal high school student would use. (To be honest, the dialogue reminds me of a 70's soap opera or something, at that point in the story)

Also, discofox, are you trying to say you liked those lines, or the story as a whole?
 
It's a nice premice, but I think the transition from "everything is normal" to "everything is not normal" is too sudden, if that makes sense. This is the key paragraph of the whole story pretty much,

There. The door opened. Her parents must be home. What would she tell them? How could she explain what had happened? How could she ever face them, knowing that she had let them down like that? She got up, and made her way down to where they would be. When she looked up, her face went white. These weren't her parents. They looked old and rotten. They looked like they had died and were simply moving about their routines on ghastly, undead clockwork.

And yet it doesn't scream out or anything, considering how much is being said in it.

I dunno, it just seems pretty unspectacular a paragraph when so much could be done with it.

Sorry I'm not very good at C&C especially stories, but I hope that helps \o_O/
 

moog

Sponsor

Because she has some problems, which you would have seen if you read through the piece a bit further than you did.

and if the response to this is "it gets better", save it. short stories are supposed to draw you in as a pre-requisite

hey what do ya know, i called it!

also yeah i skimmed in and i noticed that was possibly the main twist of the story, but as I said im not going to sit through boring writing to get to it
 
It didn't actually take very long to read at all, but I see where you're going. I've never really been a fan of short stories to be honest anyway.
 
“Ann's alarm went off, and she opened her eyes.” This is a really dull sentence to start off with. It's rather choppy and the verbs are weak. Maybe try something more like... “The blare of the alarm peeled open Ann's eyes.” Why does that sound better? First weak verbs are evil. What's a weak verb? Any “to be” verb such as “is, are, am...” is ALWAYS weak. Went is a common verb and is acceptable but always try to use verbs in weird unusual ways. Sometimes that can describe a situation better and make things more specific. If you use “peeled” what happens is you immediately understand she's tired and she woke up without saying it. Why? Peel is a force related verb that the alarm is doing to her eyes. Thus the sentence instantly becomes less worded and yet more specific and unusual so it's now more interesting. ^^ I hope you follow me on that?


“She looked out her window, where the sun was just peeking above the houses across the street.” First off, throw out “was”. So you now get “the sun peeked above the houses” it sounds stronger just by changing that. “Looked” is a bland verb. It's generic and non-specific. Maybe use glance if she's just looking fast or stare or whatever describes her action more specificly.


“The sky was filled with the wispy puffs of cumulus clouds, which floated high above the town.” Adjective overload! Adjectives are okay but use them sparingly, if you can think of a better noun then just change it. Adverbs...make them all go far far away :p. Why? What they do is just mess up the flow of things and hang the reader up on stuff. Good writing is about being short to the point and crisp, yet also describing everything in the same note. Also I think you're starting to go into over-describe mode as well. Everyone knows clouds are puffy and cumulus is just an odd word there. It's all scientific you can just use “white” if you want. Make note... whenever you use an odd word, it's going to stick out to the reader (on purpose or not). So keep that in mind.


“There was a light breeze, and the thermometer in her window read 70° Fahrenheit, the best temperature she'd seen in ages.” Over describe. Also no one cares really what temp it is. Does this add to the story really? I'd use this in a different sense. Say when she goes outside describe how good the temperature feels to her skin or whatever. It's good to try and use all five senses when describing things. You don't have to lock yourself into visual.

“She looked around her room, at the books in her bookshelf, aligned perfectly and arranged alphabetically by author then title.” You know... you're not writing in first person. She doesn't have to look around the room for you to describe what's there. It seems weird she's observing her own room.

“She looked at the calendar next to her door, the days marked clearly and concisely, with "Test Results!" in bold lettering on today's date.” Looked is boring. Too many adjectives about how it was written. Maybe try: “Her eyes attached to the calendar, resting on the words 'Test Results' etched in bold.” I leave out today because well she says it. It's not good to be redundant.

“"Oh, I get to see how I did on the test today!" She thought. "Mom and dad will be so proud of me!"” Is anyone ever excited about test results? I think the reason why a lot of people stopped dead here is because the dialogue is really unbelievable. How does she know she's going to do good? There's some fuzzy logic going on. I know why you are doing it and all that but it needs reworking as a whole... Like the idea of her being excited about the results as well as why is she happy if she failed so bad. I mean I can see getting a B or something and being depressed as a smart kid or something. But to utterly fail and yet have this type of thought before seems odd.

Well that's the first paragraph ^^ I hope that helps you a bit. I'll probably do more later if you want that kind if critique. Oh and forgive me it's been so long since I've written or edited I might be rusty.
 
Raven, you have some really good points in there. I just thought I should mention that the reason she was excited about the test results was because she was sure she had aced the test, as evidenced by the reaction in paragraph five. She had been stunned by the fact that she failed the test. In fact, that shock actually broke her world. (Which the first and second paragraphs were worded specifically to imply that she was literally being too perfect, so that there would be a bit more plausibility behind her mental state actually shattering, in the sense that she was holding herself to standards far too high for her to really be able to maintain them) That being said, lemme take a look and see if I can reword the first paragraphs, according to your advice, and still follow what I intended.

Also, one thing to note is that most people have a pretty good idea of how they did on a test, based simply on how many answers they knew they were forced to guess on, leave blank, etc. versus how many questions they could answer immediately with no hesitation.

The chirping of Ann's alarm peeled(1) open Ann's eyes. She glanced out her window, where the sun was peeked above the houses across the street. The sky was filled with wispy puffs floating high above the town. There was a light breeze rustling the leaves of the neighbors' trees. Across her room, the books in her bookshelf were aligned perfectly and arranged alphabetically by author then title. Her desk was set with a sheet of paper, with a pencil sitting on top of it. Her eyes wandered to the calendar. The days were marked clearly and concisely, with "Test Results!" catching her eye. "We get our answers back today!" She thought. "Mom and dad will be so proud of me!"

Also, that little (1) is in there because peeled is definitely not the right verb, but I can't think of the right one. I don't want to imply that she is tired. In fact, I would rather imply the opposite. The problem is, the only verb I could think of is popped, and for some reason that brought images of exploding eyes to mind, at least for me.

As for the reason I left the '"Mom and dad will be so proud of me!"' in there is because, to be honest, I can't think of anything to replace it with. It's setup for a good portion of the story, as well as an explanation of why she would force herself to be so perfect she literally snapped. She was doing it because she wanted her parents to be happy, or, more likely, because she wanted them to "love" her. (i.e. the parents are the type who don't really pay attention to her, as evidenced by the fact that they leave for work before she woke up and don't even say hi to her when they get home.) If you have any suggestions on how to make that better without ruining what it was supposed to imply, I'm all ears. I really don't like the lines either, but I can't think of what to replace them with.
 
As for the unrealism of the test result sentences... I didn't mind them at all really. Maybe that's because I've got some freaks like that in my school times, maybe it's because I'm not a literarical wizkid... it works perfectly fine to illustrate that the person in question here is apparently someone overly focussed on grades.
It is true that it doesn't serve as a nice hook at the beginning of the story, though.

Then, mostly as a reply on what Raven said... maybe it's my poor-and-Irish origin, but I didn't really mind the 'simple' words too much. You can indeed exchange most of them to make it sound better, but "Her eyes attached to the calendar, resting on the words 'Test Results' etched in bold." sounds like a line from a melodramatic theater piece, not a short story that's supposed to be readable fluently... (or at least, that's what short stories are over here).

The part you made me go :( is when I realized it was going to be either a horror story or a it-was-just-a-dream one... might be because of me, as I really was interested what you're gonna do with that girl who kinda failed what was important to her the most. So yeah, not being a big fan of horror or dream-age stories, that twist didn't really entertain me as much as I was like :|
Trying to be objective, though, I still think that's not the most original story. I definately haven't seen someone turn rafocks because of a class test, but the whole "oh god, monsters! ...shit, those were my parents..." thing is not new to me.

So, sorry I can't be the first person with substance reviewing in here that's actually voting clearly for your story, but other than moog and candle, I think all hope is not lost - you simply hit exactly my disliked category of story, big time XD
 
I hate it break it to you, but I feel like your new revised paragraph is worse. Why? Well you are telling everything. You've lost touch with the “show don't tell” everything here is using the “to be” verbs. There's was and were all over the place which drag down good writing.

“The chirping of Ann's alarm peeled(1) open Ann's eyes.” Too much Ann. Be careful of repeating too many words too closely. I have this weird rule of trying not to repeat the same words in a paragraph if that's possible and uncommon words not on the same page. I am a huge lover of pronouns. I might over use them but here you can replace that first Ann very easily and it doesn't sound so redundant. You said you wanted to use “pop” or something like it. How about flash? “The chirping of the alarm flashed Ann's eyes open.” or “Ann's eyes flashed open from the chirping of the alarm.”

“She glanced out her window, where the sun was peeked above the houses across the street.” Better on the first half but you can just rip was out and make it better... I also never care for the possession too much how about: “She glanced out the window, watching the sun peek above the houses across the street.” I didn't alter your words too much but read the two of them. It's more forward and crisp. All verbs are active.

“The sky was filled with wispy puffs floating high above the town. There was a light breeze rustling the leaves of the neighbors' trees. Across her room, the books in her bookshelf were aligned perfectly and arranged alphabetically by author then title. Her desk was set with a sheet of paper, with a pencil sitting on top of it.” And now everything is told. Was and were... can use ANY verb to make them better. Some can be easily fixed like the first one. “was filled” just use “filled”. As long as your goal isn't to up the word count it's a useless word for no reason.


“Her eyes wandered to the calendar. The days were marked clearly and concisely, with "Test Results!" catching her eye. "We get our answers back today!" She thought. "Mom and dad will be so proud of me!"” The dialogue is worse. It seems more unusual word choice to be spoken. Anything I tell you about descriptive stuff don't carry over to dialogue. That's a whole new world.

Let me try my hand at the first paragraph. I'm going to show you good use of "to be" verbs as well.
Today was the day. This was it! Ann dove out of the bed before the alarm could even ring. She snatched her neatly folded clothes placed beside her bed, all in preparation for this day she waited so long for. She swung the window open and took in a deep breath of freshly cut grass and reveled in the feel of the warmth and cool breeze on her skin. "Today is already staring out awesome!" She thought. "I just know my test results are going to be great too! Mom and dad are going to be so happy!"
:p eh I am rust as hell but I guess it gives you an idea?

---
You can indeed exchange most of them to make it sound better, but "Her eyes attached to the calendar, resting on the words 'Test Results' etched in bold." sounds like a line from a melodramatic theater piece, not a short story that's supposed to be readable fluently... (or at least, that's what short stories are over here).
Attached is a simple word. ^^ But yeah some people are like wtf at my writing when I get too carried away. I incorporate a lot of poetry to my writing (as in the fluffy imagery) which is also most of my practice comes from. But normally I am very descriptive clipped. I only describe what is crucial to the story. You won't catch me describing settings unless it's critical. But that's just a matter of preference and style and I like minimalism.
 
Well, Raven's attempt at the paragraph totally changed it from what I intended it to imply to something completely different. I'll take another look at it later today, I suppose.

Also, BlueScope, this is neither a dream nor a horror story. In fact, this story takes place long after Ann has died. The next to last paragraph is the key to that. Ann is actually in Purgatory, which is making her relive the last day of her life over and over until she does something differently. What she does when that happens will determine her final destination. That's also why the last paragraph starts with the exact same lines as the first one, to imply that instead of her waking up from a dream, the story has actually been "reset".
 

Thank you for viewing

HBGames is a leading amateur video game development forum and Discord server open to all ability levels. Feel free to have a nosey around!

Discord

Join our growing and active Discord server to discuss all aspects of game making in a relaxed environment. Join Us

Content

  • Our Games
  • Games in Development
  • Emoji by Twemoji.
    Top