Rate this music from 1-100!!!!! It would be for a boss battle! I used FL Studio.
- Thread starter shownomercy77
- Start date
zi0808":2ok6f1jn said:
thanks for this.
Overall, its decent. It took about a minute into it for it to get interesting. It doesnt sound like boss music at all in my opinion, It sounds like some psuedo-Linkin Park music. Its also constantly repetitve, like something you would play at a party. Keep at it and youll be great in no time!
UMMMMM I also Use FL Studio... I use XXL.
Buuut I didn't composed anything.. I just Imports RTP midis and transform it!
I wish sometimes to update it...but OMG I am korean and I don't know where I should keep my files OMGLOLWTH D: lol 1AERY@$46!poo!
I tried Korean server,,,,,, But it didn't work.....
and LOL! your music seems very good! I am rookie so I didn't know how to use VSTis well..
but I know how to use SoundFont Libraries;;P:
I use Sytrus VSTi and Soundfonts and VST Reverb Effects...It makes RTP music quite lol!
BBUt It is bad when in looping....It didn't loops very well.....
maybe I can try to do it on Modplug and just loop it (MOD = Module File is loopable and compact sized. but it usually can't have any effects...So It didn't make superb sound as fruity loops.)...well....bye now. I am busy.
Tuurrrrkkkk!shokah!AB240@!%
Some Joke for fun (maybe not fun) ↓
Someday, I think a rabbit would come into my pc and eat my FL
(because FL's symbol is Carrot)
Buuut I didn't composed anything.. I just Imports RTP midis and transform it!
I wish sometimes to update it...but OMG I am korean and I don't know where I should keep my files OMGLOLWTH D: lol 1AERY@$46!poo!
I tried Korean server,,,,,, But it didn't work.....
and LOL! your music seems very good! I am rookie so I didn't know how to use VSTis well..
but I know how to use SoundFont Libraries;;P:
I use Sytrus VSTi and Soundfonts and VST Reverb Effects...It makes RTP music quite lol!
BBUt It is bad when in looping....It didn't loops very well.....
maybe I can try to do it on Modplug and just loop it (MOD = Module File is loopable and compact sized. but it usually can't have any effects...So It didn't make superb sound as fruity loops.)...well....bye now. I am busy.
Tuurrrrkkkk!shokah!AB240@!%
Some Joke for fun (maybe not fun) ↓
Someday, I think a rabbit would come into my pc and eat my FL
(because FL's symbol is Carrot)
shownomercy77
Member
Mr. Moogle Sprite
about the difference between beginning, middle and end of the track there are so many opposite reviews i won't even listen to them anymore. i can't please everyone. i'm not being rude, just saying it the way i think i should. but what i didn't like in your comment, the reason why im singling it out, it's: 1st- because you say it doesn't look like boss music: if you knew the game it's for, you would realise it fits. maybe you're more into trumpets or violins and orchestral stuff or whatever, if you make music, keep doing it the exact same way as everyone else and enjoy your mediocrity. maybe i mispelled some words, but i don't speak english as first languade, so... 2nd - pseudo-linkin park song: just because i gave a linkin park song as a mere example. i have already made sad music, techno music, all kinds of music, so don't come accusing me of copying or inspiring myself too much on anything, and don't compare my music with music with lyrics whcih is not for rpgs.
about the difference between beginning, middle and end of the track there are so many opposite reviews i won't even listen to them anymore. i can't please everyone. i'm not being rude, just saying it the way i think i should. but what i didn't like in your comment, the reason why im singling it out, it's: 1st- because you say it doesn't look like boss music: if you knew the game it's for, you would realise it fits. maybe you're more into trumpets or violins and orchestral stuff or whatever, if you make music, keep doing it the exact same way as everyone else and enjoy your mediocrity. maybe i mispelled some words, but i don't speak english as first languade, so... 2nd - pseudo-linkin park song: just because i gave a linkin park song as a mere example. i have already made sad music, techno music, all kinds of music, so don't come accusing me of copying or inspiring myself too much on anything, and don't compare my music with music with lyrics whcih is not for rpgs.
shownomercy77":255il09g said:
Uh, when did I accuse you of anything? I just tried to help you out. In my opinion it DOESNT sound like boss music. Take the criticism or dont, I honestly dont give a fuck cause now it seems like you cant take truth. About the Likin Park thing, that wasnt an insult at all. Either way, I can compare it with whatever I damn please. And next, how dare you try to pull that "enjoy your mediocrity" bullshit? Thats not only a slap in the face to me, but also to everyone who orchestrates music. Man, who the hell said anything about me trying to tell you what to do? I said maybe it would sound better if you did "so and so" and in all honesty man, it probably would.
If little things I say make you upset dont even try to release any more music man. Youre not better than anyone else, your music is NO WHERE from perfect, so stop acting like it is cause your shit doesnt smell like roses.
You should know that this place is RESOURCE ANALISIS this means that ppl come here and analyze your stuff, if u dont want it to be analized it dont post it in RESOURCE ANALISIS ^^
and i agree with vinderex it wasnt a rude comment, he said it was good so your attitude is the one that doesnt look good
and i agree with vinderex it wasnt a rude comment, he said it was good so your attitude is the one that doesnt look good
shownomercy77
Member
i took pseudo linkin park music as an insult. and as i said, i didn't mean to be rude, that enjoy your mediocrity thing was a critic to everyone that doesn't innovate, not to anyone in specific, it was just the way i said it.
finalfantasyfreak
Member
That ain't music in my tastes. Its just background noise instead of background music and doesn't suit a boss battle at all. I'll rate it 1/100
mega_man_aXe
Member
You post on here asking for truth, not praise...yet you get insulted when the truth is told! We all told you how we feel about the song and suggested our thoughts. Now I suggest you take it in stride and soak it in instead of backlashing and take the time to work on your song.
Okay enough about taking crits. Get back on topic guys. Post actual opinions about the piece rather than him not taking crits. And...
Shownomercy77 this place is for analysis like others have said so please don't start arguments in here when people are only doing what you asked for. If all you want to do is advertise then I'll just lock this.
Shownomercy77 this place is for analysis like others have said so please don't start arguments in here when people are only doing what you asked for. If all you want to do is advertise then I'll just lock this.
shownomercy77
Member
Hey you are the ones who are overreacting I took lotsa critics in this thread before I answered that one in particular. Also it's a valid opinion when I say I don't agree with you, just as when you say you don't like this. This is a Resorce Analisys thread, not an One-Sided Critical Review Thread, or something like that. I can speak my mind too, I'm analysing my own resource, so I'm on topic, what the hell is the problem?
In conclusion to this topic, because if it exists it exists to a conclusion. I might have agreed with you, well, some of you, some people actually gave constructive criticism such as jtbengal, but now I've modified my music, I think it's great and I completely disagree when people say it's not boss music (there's not even such a think like boss music, THAT'S NOT BEING INNOVATIVE) and call it pseuso linkin-park music. I disagree, and have the right to disagree and take the critics I FIND CONSTRUCTIVE. I didn't insult anyone when I said what I though, so... what did I do wrong after all? maybe i seemed a little too harsh on words but that is all about how you read it because it's just words.
this was on topic cuz it was bout the quality of my resouce
off-topic edit: oh and about me being more innovative than the others: (this is my opinion, not the truth!!!!!!), most music in this site doesn't even have a clear melody, looks like some random sounds). and the ones who do look like rpg 80's music. THIS IS MY OPINION, NOT THE UNDENIABLE TRUTH, AS SOME OTHER OPINIONS)
In conclusion to this topic, because if it exists it exists to a conclusion. I might have agreed with you, well, some of you, some people actually gave constructive criticism such as jtbengal, but now I've modified my music, I think it's great and I completely disagree when people say it's not boss music (there's not even such a think like boss music, THAT'S NOT BEING INNOVATIVE) and call it pseuso linkin-park music. I disagree, and have the right to disagree and take the critics I FIND CONSTRUCTIVE. I didn't insult anyone when I said what I though, so... what did I do wrong after all? maybe i seemed a little too harsh on words but that is all about how you read it because it's just words.
this was on topic cuz it was bout the quality of my resouce
off-topic edit: oh and about me being more innovative than the others: (this is my opinion, not the truth!!!!!!), most music in this site doesn't even have a clear melody, looks like some random sounds). and the ones who do look like rpg 80's music. THIS IS MY OPINION, NOT THE UNDENIABLE TRUTH, AS SOME OTHER OPINIONS)
shownomercy77
Member
K if it wasn't meant to be an insult we're good. Sorry but sometimes, depends on my mood, I like to cause more of a stir. I even got Seifer in that Final Fantasy character test, and it said i was arrogant and competitive, so I guess it's right, lol. I know this keeps being off-topic, but I think it's ok since I am solving things. And this topic can be killed anyway, I don't feel like I need any more opinions.
Its cool man, just try not to take things so seriously! Honestly though, if I leave you a comment you should be happy because I dont really listen to much of the music on this forum.
Just tweak it a little and make sure you can take in the crits with stride. Not everyone is perfect with composing (Hell, im sure as hell not) but taking advice from fellow composers is good to do because you dont want to fall into the same trap some composers do (sour notes, bad chords, foggy melodies, etc).
Also, I hate to bring this up but:
Id have to strongly disagree. Id hope for you to look around outside the Resource Analysis forum (assuming this is the only place to look) because there are some amazing composers on this site. (miss matcha, Mattashi, Reives, Mega_man_aXe, to name a few) Seriously, if you want to improve your composing skill take a listen to some of them!
Just tweak it a little and make sure you can take in the crits with stride. Not everyone is perfect with composing (Hell, im sure as hell not) but taking advice from fellow composers is good to do because you dont want to fall into the same trap some composers do (sour notes, bad chords, foggy melodies, etc).
Also, I hate to bring this up but:
Id have to strongly disagree. Id hope for you to look around outside the Resource Analysis forum (assuming this is the only place to look) because there are some amazing composers on this site. (miss matcha, Mattashi, Reives, Mega_man_aXe, to name a few) Seriously, if you want to improve your composing skill take a listen to some of them!