Futuristic tileset WiP

[badmonur]

Im going for a sort of cell shaded/ low detail look. Tell me what you think of it so far.

Heres the WiP.

http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f251/ ... 26copy.jpg[/IMG]

And heres the reference I looked at.
http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f251/ ... 131414.jpg[/IMG]

feedback.

 

[bojox3m]

add more shadow please XD

 

[Jason]

Futuristic ? Isn't it just a rusty door ?

 

[badmonur]

Way to kill the mood jbrist. You're not helping this thread in any way. edit your post with something constructive. Thats why its WiP, foo

 

[badmonur]

ok, edits edits!!!
http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f251/ ... 27copy.jpg[/IMG]
now feedback

 

[badmonur]

I think this would be the res ingame.

http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f251/ ... hot029.jpg[/IMG]

 

[Lisker]

I like it o.o, mind me asking with what idea you made these? Like what will they represent? Will it be like a futuristic spaceship, town, house?

Could you post like a square of those tiles. I wanna see how it looks when you put many of those floor tiles together.


All in all nice job.

-Lisker

 

[badmonur]

its more of an army base like feel.

edit: heres a demo of the current tiles:

http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f251/ ... t030-1.jpg[/IMG]

 

[saikyo765]

Personally, I think it looks nice so far.
It'll look great once complete. your off to a good start

 

[NexS]

you need to put alot more texture in those futury ooking walls, but it's a great idea.. nice work!

 

[RavenTDA]

Personally I find it looks too busy. While most times in cliched furturistic setting you won't see much on the walls so you have to replace that with something... it's just the pattern is a bit much.

 

[Jason]

Way to kill the mood jbrist. You're not helping this thread in any way. edit your post with something constructive. Thats why its WiP, foo

Sorry but I see no reason why I should edit my post with something nice, with a C&C you give your opinion, and that is my opinion, it looks like a really old rusty door that was used on a submarine or something, nothing futuristic about it, sorry, but thats my opinion, and if you don't like it, don't bother posting your work, because you need people's opinions, and thats mine, and now you see it, your saying I MUST give a good opinion on something I find not-so-good.

 

[Atnas]

I agree with Raven, when I think army base I think of a simpler design. Try not to have such dark outlines, too.

 

[badmonur]

Sorry but I see no reason why I should edit my post with something nice, with a C&C you give your opinion, and that is my opinion, it looks like a really old rusty door that was used on a submarine or something, nothing futuristic about it, sorry, but thats my opinion, and if you don't like it, don't bother posting your work, because you need people's opinions, and thats mine, and now you see it, your saying I MUST give a good opinion on something I find not-so-good.

Im not saying that you should say something good i mean say something in regards to making the tileset better. You just said. Isnt it just a wall or whatever...Thats not constructive, it was just taking up space. That dosent give me anything to go on to improve. If you see an unfinished characterset would you say. But its just a shirt.....No you wouldnt. So the next time you post say something that I or anyone else can use to make it better. That my friend is constructive criticism

 

[badmonur]

you need to put alot more texture in those futury ooking walls, but it's a great idea.. nice work!

If you read the first post it says i dont want detail. Its mostly linework. Thanks for the suggestion though. Im done dicking around with this for tonight so im just going to leave you guys with an update.

http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f251/ ... t031-1.jpg[/IMG]

 

[NexS]

it's all very good and well to say that you don't want to put detal in, but that is just a cop out an an excuse to half finish a tileset. if you wish to submit these as finished work, i can almost guaruntee that no one but yourself will use them as they look to be unfinished tiles.

 

[greenninja89]

it's all very good and well to say that you don't want to put detail in, but that is just a cop out an an excuse to half finish a tileset. if you wish to submit these as finished work, i can almost guaruntee that no one but yourself will use them as they look to be unfinished tiles.

Maybe he doesn't want anyone else to use them. I sure don't want anyone else to use my tileset for my game. That dilutes the originality of the game. I think for his purpose and the look he was going for, he is on track.

 

[badmonur]

it's all very good and well to say that you don't want to put detal in, but that is just a cop out an an excuse to half finish a tileset. if you wish to submit these as finished work, i can almost guaruntee that no one but yourself will use them as they look to be unfinished tiles.

Who ware you to say its just an excuse. I have been thinking about how i wanted my game to look for over two months now. I have thought about using hand painted maps, the regular rtp, the grtp, kaizer maps and many more ideas. I came to a cross between the rtp and the grtp. And thats what I DECIDED. So I started making my tilesets in that style. You dont look at cubism art and say, well this is just a bunch of squares, its unfinnished. I wanted it to look like that for a reason and if you do your research the grtp is mostly line work. So how about you back off about the tiles thing. I already stated my point and I dont need you going over it trying to make me look out like a lazy idiot that dosent know what he is doing. Because I am sure that you know and I know that I do.

bad~

 

[Clest]

I like what you have there and I am going in a similar direction with my tilesets, it has sort oif an anime look with the outlines and the detailes, though at first it reminded me of Doom.

And don't bother so much with ppls complaints really, if they are not relevant, just don't reply to then

greenninja: I dunno if he wants other ppl using or modding his tilesets, but I find it very silly to say that sharing the tilset and having ppl use it will affect the originality of the game, afterall, tilesets can be used in many ways

 

[Rye]

The tileset look nice so far, but can you do a sample map so people know what they look like all together? As sometimes tiles individually don't look the same when paired with the other tiles (sometimes, people like me need to see something in action before they can give any good critique.)

The things that strike me so far is your color choice. When I think of future, I don't think of brighter colors. Can I ask why you chose the colors you did? Also, I like the metal plating-stuff/rusting looking-thing you have going on one some of your objects. Makes it look definately more futuristic.