Please critique this roof tile

[danyo34]

I'd like some criticism on the roof tile below. I'm just starting my first tileset, so I don't expect it to be good. This tile is intended to be used for breeze.


Edited in imgzoom tags. ~Perihelion

 

[Luthur]

Put it on imgzoom so we can critic it properly.
From what I can see, this looks pretty solid, but I can't really see the shading.

 

[danyo34]

Whenever I use imgzoom I get this.

 

[Luthur]

You have to replace the img tags with imgzoom.