Envision, Create, Share

Welcome to HBGames, a leading amateur game development forum and Discord server. All are welcome, and amongst our ranks you will find experts in their field from all aspects of video game design and development.

Help i need CRITISM

Anyway i was thinking for awhile and came up with a bit of a story for a game. I would like criticism and tell me if you don't like it because i need opinions.

The goverment has failed. America is truly dead. Through times of pandemic, war, death, and anarchy everything has failed. In a last chance the goverment hid as mobs destroyed everything. It is as if tthere is nothing. As there once was morals there is now nothing. The prisons were filled with people before the goverment was overtaken. You are a prisoner, lost to the very fact that no one remembers what happened the prisons continue to run. They are the last place that have seemed to hold up. As a "psycho" you were sent to prison for killing your whole squad in the military. This happened four years before the world seemed to die. Many of the prisoners began to question as every visit stopped. You are especially surprised when you were taken off of death row. Every day you wake up only to see more anger brewing. You hold the last newspaper you ever recieved. Every day you read it longing to see what has happened on the outside. The headline says: It's Over.
 
This belongs in concept development.

As a "psycho" you were sent to prison for killing your whole squad in the military. This happened four years before the world seemed to die. Many of the prisoners began to question as every visit stopped. You are especially surprised when you were taken off of death row.
As a psycho you'd be in an institution, not death row. Attorneys love the insanity plea when it's not the case, do you think they'd pass it up if it is?

You don't have much of a story, just a vague shadow of a scenario.

Overall, it's kind of a bland "OMG the world's ending" thing, but there's not much other than everything's dead except for prisons (which makes no sense, btw, since the prisons are run with taxpayer money. No taxpayers = no prisons).
 
Yah... This is also a little reminiscent of the fallout trilogy... You could do something similar but instead of the prison still running the guards just up and left and the main character doesn't know why. His mission is now to figure our why they took off, which then leads into him discovering crap hit the fan with the US gov
Nice concept, needs tweaking...
 
Metatron":3trq3p7r said:
This belongs in concept development.

As a "psycho" you were sent to prison for killing your whole squad in the military. This happened four years before the world seemed to die. Many of the prisoners began to question as every visit stopped. You are especially surprised when you were taken off of death row.
As a psycho you'd be in an institution, not death row. Attorneys love the insanity plea when it's not the case, do you think they'd pass it up if it is?

You don't have much of a story, just a vague shadow of a scenario.

Overall, it's kind of a bland "OMG the world's ending" thing, but there's not much other than everything's dead except for prisons (which makes no sense, btw, since the prisons are run with taxpayer money. No taxpayers = no prisons).

First of all thanks for the critique second of all the reason the "phsyco main character is in the prison rather than an institution is that at the time of his trial he did'nt have an attorney also he wasn't completely crazy at the beginning which is to be explained via flashbacks. Thirdly there is a good reason that the guards stay and it ties in with the post apocyliptia a little i'ts part of the confusion and mystery

[/quote]
Yah... This is also a little reminiscent of the fallout trilogy... You could do something similar but instead of the prison still running the guards just up and left and the main character doesn't know why. His mission is now to figure our why they took off, which then leads into him discovering crap hit the fan with the US gov
Nice concept, needs tweaking...[/quote]

Truth be told i don't know about the fallout trillogy cept number 3 and the games mainly going to be about survival for a good while of course you will be able to figure out whats going on if you are able to think:) logically speaking of course
 
Well how a prisons survives without outside help is beyond me, unless there's something story related like a nuke just happens to just barely miss it. Either way the guards if they had brains in their heads would not be sitting around in prisons that are going to end up deserted regardless, if there's no civilization why not go out and loot, prison guards can not be the most content people in the world. Also where are you hoping to go with this game? Will it just be survival? You uncover the reason behind the loss of society? You try and get back your own life?
 
Everything is good except the "prisons still running" part. To spruce it up, I suggest you make it so that the player WAS a prisoner, but when the government failed, prisons failed too, making all the prisoners escape. Then, as the story progresses, you find out more and more of how the government "failed". In the game, there are the violent prisoners, the kind prisoners, and the strange prisoners. The violent ones you fight and the kind ones act as NPC's that have multiple personalities. OMG!! That's like the coolest thing ever! Man, I wish this was my own idea and not just suggestions for you. Eh, no worries, I wouldn't be able to make something like that anyway...or maybe I would.
 
I don't no how to say what i mean without giving to much away but when i make this game nothing in it will be explainable which shall be a reason to keep playing. If this game is played through by the end people will understand.
 
But if you don't tell us we don't know if this is a reasonable concept or not, if you want feedback on what the actual story is, what takes place, the actual events you have to say them and not hold back. Your ideas won't be stolen and by the time your game is out I doubt the people who will play it will remember what you wrote here so there's nothing to lose. It's even better if you stir up interest by putting up something good then you get more feedback and attention.
 

Faine

Member

I think its kind of cliche. The world is ending, its kind of plain. You should add some more. Then ill be back.







Kryna
 
ok i didn't end this i have been having computer probs every time i logged into this site and clicked i would log off and second let me tell you a basic and unedited ending

You awake in a room with two beds, it is dark. You get up and walk to the door. A few bars are at the top with a sign under. You scream and bang on the door, what happened you wonder as you hear some people walking down the hallway."Get away from the door",a voice outside the door says. You take a few steps back as you hear the door unlock. Two people you barely recognize comes in the room. "Hold him",one of the men says as you begin to recognize their faces. They are the doctors at the mental institution you have been living at since 19 years old when you killed 40 people as who you really are. A psycopath.
 
This is a lot of "meh" at the moment. I'm not sure what you've got brewing in your head, but it's probably better than what you're typing out. I'll comment on what I can, but we can't help too much if you keep everything inside your head. :P

The goverment has failed. America is truly dead.
Just America? What about the rest of the world? This is extremely important, partially as a background element and also as a gameplay aspect. Are people from other countries going to come to America's aid? Or are they the same or worse than America. America does not equal the world~

Through times of pandemic, war, death, and anarchy everything has failed.
You need to expand on this A LOT. What war? What pandemic? When did the anarchy start and why? What caused everything to fail? Did the government(s) run out of money? Did they lose support of the people to the point that the people revolted? More details.

In a last chance the goverment hid as mobs destroyed everything.
It's good that you have organizations taking over, however I don't like the mob idea. Companies would take over before the mobs would. Unless this is in the semi-past, mobs don't have as much influence anymore, or at least not that I've heard of. Also, where do they hide? This has to be coupled with the first sentences. Are they trying to save themselves by going underground and re-organizing or do they retreat to other countries to ask for help?

It is as if tthere is nothing. As there once was morals there is now nothing.
Morals don't die. You'll still see some people preaching on the streets or creating private church-like groups. Sure, a lot of people would say "F--- this" and steal, kill, etc., but there are also a lot of people who would fight to maintain their beliefs.

The prisons were filled with people before the goverment was overtaken. You are a prisoner, lost to the very fact that no one remembers what happened the prisons continue to run. They are the last place that have seemed to hold up.
Unless this prison is on an island so that the guards can't escape or something, I don't see this as plausible. Others have expressed this concern, but you've said you have a way to deal with it. I'll trust you, but please make sure it makes sense and you're not just trying to force it.

As a "psycho" you were sent to prison for killing your whole squad in the military. This happened four years before the world seemed to die. Many of the prisoners began to question as every visit stopped. You are especially surprised when you were taken off of death row. Every day you wake up only to see more anger brewing. You hold the last newspaper you ever recieved. Every day you read it longing to see what has happened on the outside. The headline says: It's Over.
I can see this, and it could make a very good intro if you play your cards right. You need to start by creating the environment (dark, dusty, rough, etc.) and then start putting in details about what happened with the narrator/protagonist.

You awake in a room with two beds, it is dark. You get up and walk to the door. A few bars are at the top with a sign under. You scream and bang on the door, what happened you wonder as you hear some people walking down the hallway."Get away from the door",a voice outside the door says. You take a few steps back as you hear the door unlock. Two people you barely recognize comes in the room. "Hold him",one of the men says as you begin to recognize their faces. They are the doctors at the mental institution you have been living at since 19 years old when you killed 40 people as who you really are. A psycopath.
I see you changed it to a mental institution. Good choice. :wink: Now, let me make some new comments. First of all, why are there two beds? Unless he has a roommate (which I can almost guarantee he wouldn't), there don't need to be two beds. You could always add something like he killed his roommate as well, but I wouldn't just put in two beds to take up space. This room should be small and cramped and boring, so don't try to make it bigger by adding furniture.

The situation with the doctors coming in is kinda "meh". I can't really tell you how it'll work without knowing how you're planning on tying it into him escaping and such. It could make a decent intro as "before the incident" and then do a fastforward to later or something.

EDIT: Didn't see that the new post was supposed to be an ending. Apologies about that. I assumed it was an edited intro because...well, it's very blank as an ending. Without knowing anything about his situation, it doesn't make much sense. We'll need more to give you our best criticisms. (Honestly, that might make a good intro. It's a little more powerful than hangin' out in a prison cell.)
 
i have been to mental institutions before (visitor no im not a patient btw if anyone makes jokes about people in mental institutions i will beat u because its one of my immediate family) anyway i have been to three but yes most people have roomates also its a good point that if he was so dangerous he wouldnt have one so ill reflect on this the thing im getting at is he is now a psycho at one time he comitted his crime and went to jail after jail he went to a mental institution the game takes place in his head through dreams and stuff in the game you are rliving certain aspects of his life btw his earlier life in the military was not an intro more as flashbacks. Some people experience things and fill in the blanks for example the post apocaliptica hes in is only his mind compensating the fact that when he went outside for recreation he was in the mid of the desert with no one so in other words ur playing as a character in the imagination of a mentally insane person
 

Thank you for viewing

HBGames is a leading amateur video game development forum and Discord server open to all ability levels. Feel free to have a nosey around!

Discord

Join our growing and active Discord server to discuss all aspects of game making in a relaxed environment. Join Us

Content

  • Our Games
  • Games in Development
  • Emoji by Twemoji.
    Top